First a word of caution prior to the 1980s tar paper and roofing felt often contained asbestos so it s important to have the material tested before attempting to remove it.
Asbestos paper under hardwood.
Older flooring felt may contain asbestos making its removal critical.
Not uncommon on old fir or pine subfloors.
Used to be we just took a machine to it not knowing about asbestos.
An added benefit when laying wood floors over plywood is the absorption of vibration by the felt which results in a reduction of noise.
If the material tests positive for asbestos your best bet is to either leave it alone and cover over it with new flooring or have the material professionally removed by an asbestos remediation company.
The asbestos threat is a little overblown but serious enough to take heed.
Common in homes built in the 20th century black mastic was used as an adhesive for ceramic tile linoleum and other flooring materials.
When you remove that floor covering to make way for new flooring you may encounter the mastic and wonder whether it is safe to remove the main concern surrounding this question is that black mastic often contains asbestos.
Hmmm ending in the 1950 s but when did they start using asbestos in that stuff.
If what you found under the vinyl is roofing paper commonly used under flooring and it dates to before the late 1970 s it is possible there is asbestos fiber in it asbestos fiber was commonly used in roofing materials until it was outlawed as stated the only real danger in this is if you create an airborn dust otherwise the asbestos is locked into the material.
No scraping or sanding would help.
If it has no asbestos it can simply be sanded off with a drum sander and a very low grit paper 12 16 or 24 whatever it takes.
I have just the right amount of click type bamboo flooring suitable for below grade with 3mm thick underlayment and would like to use that.
Vapor concerns concerns about roofing felt stem from the bituminous impregnating agents tar and asphaltic bitumen and whether fumes from the felt may rise into rooms.
The real problem was the installer glued the carpet with a product that melted the residue from the tar paper into the wood.
Widespread use in building materials wasn t until the 1930 s.
Hardwood floor underlay until maybe the 1950 s up to 85 asbestos.
Now we d like to put hardwood flooring in avoiding removal of the existing floor since it contains asbestos.
However old asbestos felt remains in the floors and roofs of millions of american buildings constructed between 1900 and 1980.
Flooring felt or tar paper is sometimes laid under tile flat carpeting or old linoleum.
A house we bought had carpet in the kitchen.
Iirc asbestos was first used in the 1890 s in small and specialized applications.
We we pulled it up it had tar paper under it.